Looking at the quick success achieved by Ajanta Pharma and Thangamayil Jewellery, it seems that making money is so easy in Indian Markets, but it isn't.
They were able to achieve the early success because they were able to post numbers beyond expectations most of the times.
In small caps, as they say, posting numbers which are just as expected doesn't light up the eyes of big investors who actually has the capacity to take the stock to new levels.
For eg., We saw in Ajanta Pharma that, it used to make nearly 10000 volumes a day, on a consistent basis. But suddenly, from 23rd Jan (i.e. the day when they declared results), I haven't seen the stock doing volumes even less than 1.5 lakhs in a day. So, was there a sudden change in fundamentals of the company?
The answer is No. It is just that, big institutes, suddenly fell in love with the company's fundamentals and they took the stock to new levels. And this could happen any day with any company. Not just the day when they post strong numbers.
If we go back and say that Ajanta Pharma posted a strong Q3 numbers due to which the stock went up, then let me remind all, that this time, Ajanta Pharma's revenues went up by 40% YoY and net profits went up 75% YoY, whereas if you check Q2 results, their revenues again went up by 40% and net profit actually went up by 85%. But still the stock got hammered after Q2 results, it came down from 447 to 358 levels and this time, it went up from 409 to 670 levels. So, this is something, I feel, one cannot predict, but we atleast try to be sure, that it will happen some day.
They were able to achieve the early success because they were able to post numbers beyond expectations most of the times.
In small caps, as they say, posting numbers which are just as expected doesn't light up the eyes of big investors who actually has the capacity to take the stock to new levels.
For eg., We saw in Ajanta Pharma that, it used to make nearly 10000 volumes a day, on a consistent basis. But suddenly, from 23rd Jan (i.e. the day when they declared results), I haven't seen the stock doing volumes even less than 1.5 lakhs in a day. So, was there a sudden change in fundamentals of the company?
The answer is No. It is just that, big institutes, suddenly fell in love with the company's fundamentals and they took the stock to new levels. And this could happen any day with any company. Not just the day when they post strong numbers.
If we go back and say that Ajanta Pharma posted a strong Q3 numbers due to which the stock went up, then let me remind all, that this time, Ajanta Pharma's revenues went up by 40% YoY and net profits went up 75% YoY, whereas if you check Q2 results, their revenues again went up by 40% and net profit actually went up by 85%. But still the stock got hammered after Q2 results, it came down from 447 to 358 levels and this time, it went up from 409 to 670 levels. So, this is something, I feel, one cannot predict, but we atleast try to be sure, that it will happen some day.
1) Granules India Ltd:
The company, right now is going through the toughest time of their career in stock markets, even after posting a record revenues of 195 Crs this quarter. The reason being, people expected it to post numbers which included the revenues from the capacity expansion by the company in this quarter. The only option left for management to get back the faith of investors (atleast those same investors, who took the stock from 55 to 230 levels within 9 months), is to make some positive announcements. One can be further promoter buying, for the remaining 0.5% allowed for the year, one can be through a notice suggesting the completion of capacity expansion and making sure that they contribute to sales for this quarter, and last one would be to wait and watch this quarter results directly in April.
Somehow, the company needs to get out of the tough times.
The company, right now is going through the toughest time of their career in stock markets, even after posting a record revenues of 195 Crs this quarter. The reason being, people expected it to post numbers which included the revenues from the capacity expansion by the company in this quarter. The only option left for management to get back the faith of investors (atleast those same investors, who took the stock from 55 to 230 levels within 9 months), is to make some positive announcements. One can be further promoter buying, for the remaining 0.5% allowed for the year, one can be through a notice suggesting the completion of capacity expansion and making sure that they contribute to sales for this quarter, and last one would be to wait and watch this quarter results directly in April.
Somehow, the company needs to get out of the tough times.
2) Cravatex Ltd:
The company posted Q3 numbers on 8th Feb, and not surprisingly, they were again below expectations. The revenues went down by 10% YoY and net profit took a severe hit, and was down almost 58% YoY.
They would find it difficult to get back to heavy profits, unless the rupee gets stronger. Till then, they should find ways to grow their revenues more and more.
The updated website looks cool and promising, but it is definitely going to be tough for them, as the investors had lots of expectations from the company, just a year back, when it made a high of 799 Rs around April, and that was after the company provided bonus shares 1:1
Let's see, if the company is able to weather this storm and get back the confidence of investors in future.I have found a quote for both the companies and it says:
"Prosperity is a great teacher; adversity is a greater. Possession pampers the mind; privation trains and strengthens it"
The company posted Q3 numbers on 8th Feb, and not surprisingly, they were again below expectations. The revenues went down by 10% YoY and net profit took a severe hit, and was down almost 58% YoY.
They would find it difficult to get back to heavy profits, unless the rupee gets stronger. Till then, they should find ways to grow their revenues more and more.
The updated website looks cool and promising, but it is definitely going to be tough for them, as the investors had lots of expectations from the company, just a year back, when it made a high of 799 Rs around April, and that was after the company provided bonus shares 1:1
Let's see, if the company is able to weather this storm and get back the confidence of investors in future.I have found a quote for both the companies and it says:
"Prosperity is a great teacher; adversity is a greater. Possession pampers the mind; privation trains and strengthens it"
Thangamayil Jewellery Ltd has informed BSE that the Company is opening its 26th (TWENTY SIXTH) branch at Thirupur — on February 13, 2013, Wednesday between 9.00 Am and 10.00 Am admeasuring 2746 sqft.
ReplyDeletePhotoquip -Results for the Quarter ended December 2012 are satisfactory ! As expected by me Company is incurring extra-expenditure on product and brand promotion, advertisement, and hiring additional manpower. Therefore, inspite of sales being lower for the last two quarters and for the 9 month period ended December 2012 - other expenditure has gone up by more than Rs.2 crores as well as employees expenditure is also more !!!! Now the key question will be success of CORVI !!!
ReplyDeleteResults looks decent to me, obviously if we ignore the fact that last year same quarter, they made 23.58 Crs.
ReplyDeleteQuarterly, sales have gone up by nearly 25%.
The thing that impressed me the most is the expenditure.
All the expenses seems to be paying them off in the long term, that seems to be a good sign, as you pointed out..
Fair Numbers from Photoquip this time as expected.
ReplyDeleteSales stands at 19.8 Crs, which suggests 25% jump QoQ and 19% fall YoY.
But this fall in revenues and net profit YOY usually happens, when company changes its focus area. (From only Elinchrome to CORVI now)
As per management, CORVI sales will show up in revenues from next quarter.
The good thing about the results this time, seems to be the expenses. Employee expense just got doubled, which is great news.
Being in the service industry myself, I know when the company, is in a position to spend more on employees.
To be sure, I will get the details from company regarding the progress in CORVI, and will update soon.
This is the reply that I got from Photoquip's management:
ReplyDeleteHi Kunal
At the outset I thank you for continuing to repose confidence and being a part of the Photoquip family.
We have started commercial production of CORVI products with effect from 12.12.2012. As informed to you earlier CORVI products will be contribute substantially in the Q4 of FY 2012-13. As of now 4 products are already out in the market. We will continue our R & D to develop further products for FY 2013-14.
Regards,
Vivek
I have personally seen their three products !!!! They will have to bring entire range as they are competing with established outfits both Desi and MNC ! Let us hope that their R & D will be very active in FY2013-14 ! Meanwhile, good accumulation is taking place at the hands of Promoters. Obviously, they must be visualising the growth prospects ! It can prove to be a multibagger provided promoters are interesting is seeing the value at stock exchange front !
ReplyDeleteC Krishna Prasad got another 1.6 Lakhs shares of Granules India released from Pledge.
ReplyDeleteIn my view, these steps assure that there hasnt been any change in the fundamentals of the company. It is just a bad phase through which company is going.
http://www.moneycontrol.com/livefeed_pdf/Feb2013/Granules_India_Ltd_180213_SAST.pdf
High power costs to drag margins of pharma firms:
ReplyDeletehttp://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-company/earnings/earnings-analysis/high-power-costs-to-drag-margins-of-pharma-firms/articleshow/18594320.cms
Seems a temporary problem...
Hi Kunal,
ReplyDeleteCan you share your views on Money matters and vikas wsp. I am holding these shares at Rs. 160 and Rs. 58 respectively. They are falling continuously. Kindly suggest me whether I hold them or book loss. I am a mid term investor. Thanks in advance.
Money Matters, I think is falling mainly because of the weakness in the finance sector...
ReplyDeleteIts very important to note what's the next move from promoters around April. Since last 2 years, they have been buying 5% shares around April-May....
If they do it again this year, then I am sure its still a very good buy...and we can surely expect the stock to hit 275 in next 1 years or so....
The movements in Vikas WSP is even surprising for me.
ReplyDeleteThe good thing is that last year their promoters bought plenty of shares at 60-70 levels, and still they havent sold a single quantity out of that. That is, to an extent boosting my confidence in the company.
This again would be a similar case, where we will have to wait for further promoters activity in FY14, starting April this year, and then take our decision.
Thangamayil Jewellery New Ad:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVQ04mleFQs
All the advertisement expense, that contributed to muted profits last quarter are seen now...
Ajanta Pharma promoters still buying even at these levels.....
ReplyDeleteAmazing to see...
http://www.moneycontrol.com/livefeed_pdf/Mar2013/Ajanta_Pharma_Ltd_040313_SAST.pdf
I think we will have to reduce the time frame given for the target of 1000 now... :P
Around 50000 shares bought from open market by promoters on last Friday(28th Feb)...
ReplyDeleteI missed the 2nd report which I saw while scrolling down...
ReplyDeleteA total of 56000 shares are bought on 28th Feb and 1st March....
The total buying values comes out to be 6.36 Crs approx...
That is huge...
Another important news:
ReplyDeleteJust on delivery basis, volumes on Thangamayil are approximately 1.4 Lakhs, which is not possible, unless promoters intervene....
Hoping for a buying report from promoters soon...
Another Promoter buying report out for Ajanta.
ReplyDeleteThis time they took approx 3000 shares on 4th March...
http://www.moneycontrol.com/livefeed_pdf/Mar2013/Ajanta%20Pharma_8.pdf
Looks like we have a better than expected Q4 in store for us...
Ajanta Pharma hits new high of 697..
ReplyDeleteMight cross 700 soon..
Promoter's decision of buying heavily around 600 again proved to be correct....
With that, we have another report from promoters suggesting a buy of another 3000 shares on 5th March....it should worth close to 20 Lakhs....
ReplyDeleteThe reason for pressure on Thangamayil.....
ReplyDeletehttp://www.thehindubusinessline.com/markets/stock-markets/jewellery-stocks-slump-on-mandatory-kyc-norms/article4509270.ece?homepage=true&ref=wl_home
The CORVI project has gone commercial from 14.1.2013. The products are very well received in the market and are gaining popularity pan-India as per our expectations. For the records we have won 2 international design awards for 3 products of the CORVI range.
ReplyDeleteThe results are encouraging and we will strive to continue the efforts.
Above are the feedback received from Company Secretary, Photoquip India Ltd.
Posted by totalview on respective post...
It seems that Money Matters Financial Services Ltd (MMFSL) promoters are getting ready for another 5% buy out once FY14 starts which is just 5 days away now....
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, because of this, the price has been brought down.....so that they can accumulate 5% at lower levels....
In past few days, there has been heavy delivery of shares, which I think, has been taken up by management proxies, though whom, they will acquire once April starts...
We can just wait and watch...
This is just my opinion, I will wait till I get the report of buying from the management...
Very heavy volumes also seen on Thangamayil in last few days, and all going into delivery...
ReplyDeleteDont know who, but someone is surely utilizing these cheap valuations to get as many shares as possible...
In past 2 months, we saw that there were good amount of shares that went into delivery in Photoquip India Ltd., but we didnt see any reports of promoter buying...
ReplyDeleteThe secret is revealed today.
All these days, Javed Saiyed, used to buy all the shares, from open market, being a promoter's proxy, and now today, he has transferred all the shares into promoter's account.
Volumes on photoquip were 1.46 Lakhs within just first 5 mins of trade today.....and now we have the reason why.
Today, was the last day of FY13, and promoters had to complete 5% acquisition for the year...
In my opinion, something seriously big, has to happen with photoquip....
Wait is still longer for Photoquip investors !FY 2012-13 end should see promoters' holding at 58%+ ! And they can carry out their acquisition-spree for atleast another three years i.e.FY 2015-16 !!!! As per my calculation they have around 5% holding with proxies(at present)after 2012-13 creeping acquisition. They will require another 10% to 12% to complete their game-plan. Therefore, investors will have to be in meditation-mode for atleast three-years. In the meantime, business will also unfold and possibly bloom !!!! What a co-incidence ! Isn't it?
ReplyDeleteBut that I think, is not completely upto the promoters once the company starts performing well...
ReplyDeleteOne example I can think of is MMFSL once the issues related to scam were over...
In April 2011, promoters bought 5% shares at 47 Rs....then in April 2012, they had to buy 5% shares at around 76 Rs... as the performance was exceedingly well...
Promoters tried their best, but were not able to keep it down...when they started buying in 2012, stock was trading around 85-90, but somehow they managed to buy around 76...
Again this year, close to April, they have brought the share price down from 160 to 105 levels..... and now they might have to buy around 95-100 levels this time...as it seems so far..
One reason, why Photoquip didn't shoot up was that, the performance of the company was not consistent.
ReplyDeleteAfter 2 good quarters, suddenly they have a horrible quarter in between, which again brings the price down...especially in 2012-13
What I feel is that once CORVI products starts becoming well known in market, then we can see a consistent performance by the company....and CAGR might go upto 30-35% for next 5 years or so...
Right now, it seems that its best to wait and watch...
As I am already holding a huge amount in the company, I dont feel there is any need of buying more from my side....
But we must admit that promoters have been very smart and they saw to it that they were able to keep the price in the range of 40 for quite a longer period !!! My worry on this counter is a little different ! Suppose even after acquisition and performance share price refuses to budge !!!! Promoters' conduct on corporate governance is far from satisfactory !!! They have not declared dividend since inception whereas they have been taking handsome salary packages for father and two sons !!! In fact, it is exorbitantly high keeping in view the size of the company and it's operations !!! There is no guarantee that they will come on the dividend list even after everything is done as per their wish-list !!!! I can quote you so many companies whereas handsome profits are being recorded year after year and companies are refusing to reward the shareholders.In fact, minority shareholders are being treated like a step child. Our present Corporate laws provide hardly any remedy arising out of such a situation. Ultimately, retail shareholders are left with no option except to accept any "sell out" coming from the promoters or even no reflection of performance on the share prices. With the result share prices are quoting at laughable prices. For example just check up "Samtex Fashions" !!!!!
ReplyDeleteAgreed...but why should we link such rare cases with Photoquip....
ReplyDeleteTo add to your point, we also had a stock Essar Steel Ltd., which came out with an IPO in 94' (approx)at a price of 60 Rs.....and then after 13-14 years, promoters delisted the stock around 48 Rs..... inspite of strong performance by the company internally.
I said internally because, there was a speculation that the management didnt show the actual numbers in quarterly results....
They hid the actual profit figures which helped them delist the stock around 48 Rs...
Management transparency is very important factor in market...and probably thats only reason why photoquip hasnt gone up inspite of such innovations...
But I am still hopeful, because whenever I have mailed the company, they have given me a very positive and confidence boosting response..
Hence, for now, I would say, lets wait and watch... :)
No doubt Company Secretary has been very communicative and responsive ! Let me also hope that after their wish-list is done they are investor-friendly. After all one of the parameters of the success of a brand is measured by the valuation of the Company ! And that is how brands are measured and evaluated !!!! But next three or four quarters will conclude the fate of their CORVI project as well as fairly old Elinchrome franchise !
ReplyDeletehttp://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/ajanta-pharma-at-new-high-stock-surges-106-in-2013-113040300181_1.html
ReplyDeleteThangamayil promoters using every dips to buy shares..
ReplyDeleteGood Sign..
http://www.moneycontrol.com/livefeed_pdf/Apr2013/Thangamayil_Jewellery_Ltd_050413_SAST.pdf
Money Matters promoters once again has bought 5% shares from open market on 4th and 5th April.
ReplyDeleteSo, luckily, the prediction mentioned earlier proved to be true.
I feel one can invest in the stock for long term. It can prove to be a great multibagger in future...
Coming up with a whole new post on Money Matters soon...
ReplyDeleteHere is the promoter buying report...
ReplyDeletehttp://www.moneycontrol.com/livefeed_pdf/Apr2013/Money%20Matters_44.PDF
I made a mistake in a post earlier....they havent acquired 5% stake....they have started the process...
ReplyDeleteRight now, we got report for buying of almost 5 Lakh shares...
I think 5% shares would be somewhere around 15-16 Lakh shares.... so, still the process should continue for next few days....
But ofc, its a great news...
Waiting to reach this rally up to 1k for ajanta dude.
ReplyDeleteGranules India announced financial results for its fiscal year 2013 ended March 31, 2013. Granules consolidated net sales increased 17 per cent to Rs 764 crore while consolidated net profit increased nine per cent to Rs 33 crore.
ReplyDeleteThe company reported sales of Rs 204 crore., its highest ever, in Q4FY13, an increase of 9 per cent compared to the comparable quarter in FY12. In addition, PBT before F/X increased by 15 per cent to Rs 18 crore.
Granules also announced the completion of the expansion at its Gagillapur Facility. The company has commenced operations of the new capacity and expects to scale up operations over the next several months. Due to the delay in the scale-up of the new capacity, margins slipped since the company incurred costs to run the new facility without a concurrent increase in production. The company expects margins to increase since production is increasing at the facility.
“While we faced a setback in scaling-up our formulation expansion, we are optimistic for the future. Our strategy has enabled us to entrench ourselves within our industry and become synonymous with the products we produce. Due to our ability to provide high-quality products at a cost effective price, we have been able to work closely with market leaders which has resulted in sustainable revenue. We have made significant improvements over the past year and believe our foundation is stronger than ever. In FY14, we’ll continue to shift to formulations which will result in an improvement in profitability.” said Krishna Prasad, Managing Director of Granules India.