Tuesday, February 21, 2017

Q3 FY'17 Result Updates

I am sharing few thoughts initially, which are strictly mine and has no intention of driving any investors to any conclusion.

This was probably the most anticipated result season for past many quarter, as Indian economy went through a major reform in form of demonetisation of major currency notes with an intention of curbing the black money. The same was bound to have negative impact on various sectors and their growth, and eventually the growth of nation, as one cannot deny the extensive use of black money in India, especially among the companies from un-organised sector. Among the organised ones, the impact was expected to be maximum in real estate & construction sector, followed by auto sector and then to some of the sectors which are directly related to those 2 sectors like furnishing, cement and auto-ancillary, to name a few. Every body was anxious about how the numbers would turn out to be for companies in those sectors, and how management would ensure investors confidence in their respective companies.

The above para negative mindset about the government's move on Indian market, however, as usual, there are always 2 sides of the coin, and demonetization was no different. There are few positives as well, but most of them will take time to reflect in form of numbers, and hence are lesser discussed then the negative ones. The move is expected to improve government spending, especially in infrastructure, which would benefit the nation and indirectly benefit some of the companies from the most beaten down sector i.e. construction and real estate. The move in fact, is also expected to bring down inflation and hence the interest rates, which would enable common people to invest more in properties and their vehicular needs.

Coming to numbers, I feel that they were not as bad as it was expected,.

Ajanta Pharma continues to post decent growth, aided by huge growth coming from US market, where it had almost negligible presence till last year. The growth from some of its larger export market seems to be flattening, which can be considered as a reason to worry. But if US and India continues to contribute well, they should not see a major impact in their overall growth. Margin continues to outperform peers which is a big positive. The stock might still continue to act as steady compounder for next few years.

Granules India also posted decent numbers. With company trading around 18 P/E and having lots of positive triggers in next 2 years, most of the brokerage houses are bullish on the company and have given their targets in the range of 150-220. Recently, one of World Bank unit IFC has confirmed investment up to 47.5 million dollars in the company, which shows their confidence in future of the company.

Can Fin Homes and Dewan Housing has shown superb run away rally in past few days, as it is assumed that NBFCs are most likely to benefit from the government's move. Both of them are well on track and have continued their performance even in last quarter. Capri Global somewhere falls in the same category and hence is also likely to benefit. Some of the new names that I have come across in the sector, are Bajaj Finance and PNB Housing Finance, which obviously have run up a lot in past, but still from a business perspective, they seem to have very bright future. Currently, I am not holding either of them, on account of lack of cash in hand.

Now coming to one of my favorite sector, which unfortunately took a hit on account of demonetization i.e. home furnishing, where we have been tracking Cera Sanitaryware and Somany Ceramics from long time. The good part was that both the companies outperformed their peers and posted results which were much better than expectations, and accordingly market has rewarded them. Even in times of crisis, both of them are not very far from their all time highs. I continue to remain positive on both of them.

Coming to another sector which was indirectly expected to take a hit on account of such move, is auto ancillary. We have been mainly tracking SSWL and FIEM Ind from that sector. The results were surprisingly contradictory. Even in such a quarter, SSWL showed 19% growth in sales which is phenomenal. The same was mostly aided by sales in truck and tractor segment which has seen significant uptick in recent times. In fact, on account of that the company even raised its sales target for this quarter. The profit saw a decline, but as I always say, I won't mind company posting de-growth in profit for one or two quarter, if their sales growth in on track. And as such, if you see, the company is still trading around 15 P/E. I know debt is a concern, but one needs to consider nature of business and the fact that they have not let it increase in past 4 years. The stock has already appreciated close to 200% from the time we started the discussion here. Talking about FIEM, the sales saw a decline, which was quite obvious, as 2 wheeler sales were most impacted in the auto sector, and 96% of their revenues come from there. Even in that sector, Honda Motors saw the biggest de-growth which is the highest contributor to FIEM revenues. So, considering all these, I don't think the numbers were bad. I won't comment on price, as it has already seen good appreciation from the time we started its discussion.

No change in views for PI Ind and Dhanuka Agritech. Both seems to be doing very well, and accordingly they are trading at almost their all time high levels.

Garware Wall Ropes is getting better and better with every quarter, and seems to quite easily achieve the management's vision of 2020. Sales growth was moderate on account of decline in domestic sales due to demonetization but it was offset by higher exports, which is very good sign. Growth would certainly be higher once the domestic impact is over.

Lincoln Pharma has continued to see a decline in sales, because of the fact that they have stopped their trading business in India. However, the sales of their core products is growing fast. The decline in sales seems temporary. The margins are also improving thick and fast. The contribution from exports of branded products is also increasing and management is expecting it to contribute 50% of the total revenues in next 3-4 years. It might look cheap at current market price, but may be market is in a wait and watch strategy, as it might not be fully convinced with management words. Who knows!!!

Salzer Electronics has continued to face challenges, on account of lesser orders from EMS compared to last year. Also sudden rise in commodity price kept the profits under check. The company has decided to increase the price from Jan onwards, which will help regain their margin levels. Good part is that the company has received order worth 18.7 Cr in that segment recently. The other positives being that the company has started the commercial production and invoicing of Three Phase Dry Type Transformers from Jan'17. Also the company received its first order from Smith's Detection which is a German based company manufacturing Airport Security X-Ray Machines and received first order from Alstom. All in all, it seems that they have few triggers for growth in future. 4th quarter numbers will be interesting to watch out for.

Srikalahasthi Pipes, one of the companies we started discussing off-late, is also from a sector which was likely to get impacted. However, the impact in results seems to be very limited. The growth in sales and profit both were flat yoy, which is not bad considering the situation in the sector. Also, the margins continued to remain at same levels, and much higher than its peers. If we go by what management said while the shutdown was going on in Q2, the Q4 numbers should be pretty good, as they did not reduce their annual guidance, in spite of one month shutdown in that quarter. Higher debt levels, lesser transparency of management towards investors, and non-performance of other group companies continues to keep the stock below 10 P/E, but lets see for how long, if they keep on performing well. The increased spending in infra, post demonetization should also help the company get good number of orders.

Next in the list is Force Motors. Results as expected saw a 15% decline in sales as well as profits. One of the reason was mild decline in sales of luxury cars (Mercedes and BMW), which is very likely to recover in Q4, and hence indirectly helping Force Motors. Company is having very good market share in LCV segment, where demand is expected to rise after one lackluster quarter. Also with new models launched by the company in that segment, their market share might increase further.

Kitex Garments posted another strong set of numbers, and it seems that the management confidence as seen in the concall post few major concerns in the past, does not seem to be over optimistic. However, market will always take its own time, before giving back the similar valuation to the company, as it had in the past.

Poddar Pigments also delivered good numbers, and it continues to enjoy decent market share along with Plastiblends in the sector. Plastiblends has been followed here since long time, but with the expectation of masterbatches industry growing at around 15-20% CAGR for next 5 years, I thought it isn't a bad idea to go ahead with 2nd largest company in that sector as well. Plastiblends has already given multiple returns since we started discussing.

Pricol also saw a minor impact on account of government's move. However, even there the impact is not expected to last long with most of the auto companies getting their sales back on track. The company was not getting traded from Dec to mid Fed on account on procedural reasons due to the amalgamation taken up by the company. With excellent customer base, both from domestic as well as international auto companies, and with good market share of some of its products in the industry, the company might well get back to good growth from Q4.

Discloure:
I am not a research analyst, nor an investment advisor. Through this post, I am only putting my views, and which has nothing to do with any action that can be taken by readers on any specific company.
 

52 comments:

  1. Excellent as usual thanks for update.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Kunal this is certainly helping us in taking decision with our investment
    Thanks again - Ramesh

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ramesh, just keep it restricted to only helping.
      It should not directly drive your decision, as I am not a financial expert. Please consult your advisor before taking a call.

      Thanks!!

      Delete
  3. Thanks for the update.
    are you tracking banco products?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Quite positive on the company. Good management, consistent dividend payer with high yield, decent growth and excellent balance sheet.
      Q3 numbers were sort of flat, mostly on account of demonetisation, which was expected, though I feel, the impact not that huge and things should get back on track from Q4 for the company.

      Regards.

      Delete
  4. Sir Kunal
    thanks for the valuable advise.
    I need your oponion on 3 stock
    Shree Pushkar Chemicals & Fertilizers Ltd
    ambika cotton
    ARCHIDPLY INDUSTRIES LTD

    And Many Many Thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Gulame Ahmed,

      Out of the 3, I am quite positive on Shree Pushkar. Have been tracking it myself, and thinking of taking a position in it. As such, the stock is definitely not undervalued, but I am very hopeful on its future growth, looking at expansion plans and management's commentary on the same.
      Also, the margins posted by the company is one of the highest in the industry and they are quite hopeful of sustaining it.

      Not tracking other 2.

      Regards!!

      Delete
  5. KUNAL SIR, UR VIEW ON NEEL KAMAL and hov services

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In Nilkamal, one can rely more on its future business growth rather than on current valuation. I hope you can read between the lines.

      In the specific sector, I feel Hinduja Global & Allsec Tech are slightly better placed than HOV. Just my opinion.

      Regards!!

      Delete
  6. u have not been updating us on swiss glascoat, one of ur earlier reco, even when it is hitting new highs daily?
    -Mayank

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mayank, frankly speaking, I am not tracking the stock deeply nowadays, because I think that the stock is showing tremendously volatility not based on its performance, but on the basis on other surrounding news, one of which is Open Offer.
      The performance in past few quarters was not as good as I was expecting earlier, which is why I am lesser interested in its rally.

      Regards.

      Delete
  7. hi kunal
    can you please update about suven life still positive

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is always difficult to call when the stock you discussed has already gone up by 7 times, i.e. at current market price. Overall, it went up by more than 10 times.
      However, I would say that the rally which came immediately after stock getting discussed here, was more because of pre-launch of various molecules, which led to some 100% growth in sales in FY'14 yoy. If you see the larger picture, the company posted sales of 257 Cr in FY'13 and is likely to post sales of about 550 Cr in FY'17, which is definitely not bad. The journey became roller coaster because of inconsistent growth, which was mainly due to above reason.
      It got appreciated also for the same reason. If one looks at it now from FY'13, the sales has more than doubled and stock has gone up by 7 times, which can be categorized as good performance.
      Now it will all depend on how company performs in future, and based on how many patents have they got in past few years, it seems commercialization of those will lead to decent growth in future.
      Margins have always been superb for the company, because of its presence in high margin business. Things look good as of now, but only for long term.

      Regards!

      Delete
  8. Nice to see you back Sir,
    I have a question. What happened to TCPL Packaging? No movement for the past two years.
    Regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Bhanu, I was here only, may be you might missed my earlier post. I am writing new threads post every quarterly numbers.

      Regarding TCPL, I think the dip in growth is keeping the stock price in check. The profits have been at same level for past 3 years now, where as debt has increased by huge amount, which is not welcomed by investors. However, with commercialization of new facility, one can expect better growth in future.
      For now, I will take wait and watch call on this.
      They need to improve their margins, because sales are still growing at slow pace, but profits are stagnant.

      Let's see.

      Delete
  9. Dear Sir,

    What's your current view on Astra Microwave? Last i had asked you the same question some 2 years back and your reply was It's good company with Long term view... So i am holding on to it patiently... Do you see any positive price movement in coming days as its revolving in a range from very long time?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Navin, as such I am not deeply tracking the company, but, I liked the prospectus of the company then, which is why I had said that I like it with long term view. And obviously all views are considering the current situation, which were better then, and which might or might not remain same over the years, and hence I am posting updates every quarter for the stocks that I am deeply tracking.
      For Astra Microwave, the order inflows declined, which led to major degrowth in FY'16 and probably first half of FY'17. As far as what I have read, the order inflows have increased off-late and considering the fact that there has been 10% increase in defence budget, things are likely to improve.
      But as I said, I am not tracking the company as such, please take advise from finance expert before taking a call.

      Regards.

      Delete
    2. Thanks a Lot Kunal Sir for you genuine advise and guidance time to time....

      Delete
  10. Hi Kunal, any idea why promoter stake decreased in Fiem Ind?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mayur, I didn't find any decline in promoter stake as on Dec'16. And even after that, I didn't find any disclosures related to sale of shares by promoters. Could you please share the link. I might have missed.

      Regarding performance in Q3, as I said earlier, decline in sales of Honda Motors was highly responsible. The good part is that the sales are now flattening out for both TVS Motors and Honda Motors, as seen in sales data for Jan and Feb. Even with their flat sales, I think the company will be able to post decent numbers in coming quarters. Q4 and Q1 of FY'18, will be interesting to watch out for. Will surely share my update post those numbers.

      Regards!!!

      Delete
  11. Hi Kunal, Do you track any stocks from BSE/NSE SME segment?

    Regards,
    Venu.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Sir anything wrong with Pricol... Its going down very fast or it is just Amalgamation blues?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sandeep, as such I am not aware of negatives apart from the fact that there are uncertainties related to amalgamation, and promoter selling from open market just before temporary delisting.
      The upcoming results can be one of the positive trigger which could drive the stock price going ahead. Wait and watch as of now.

      Regards!

      Delete
  13. pls share your views on your old recommendation dynemic products.
    - Nayan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It has already given good returns post initiation on this blog. However, I am not tracking the same as of now...

      Delete
  14. Thank for suggestion any specifc reason for indo count up movement?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I always say, I never expect any of the stocks to start making highs from day I am invested in it.
      Time to time, I keep on checking whether there are any changes in fundamentals of the company. If not in negative direction, then I stay invested in it for long. Reward is not something you can predict when it will start coming.

      One of the best examples of that is Steel Strip Wheels, as I mentioned recently in one of my post. It was trading at same range for nearly 3-4 years, but then when it started shooting, it gave 200% returns in less than a year. Now if I see, its not bad if company has given you 200% returns in 4 years overall. And you never know, how much more reward it can give in coming years.

      Regards!!

      Delete
  15. gap u talked about between srikala and apl has started getting filled it seems. srikala has showed tremendous rally in last 3 months.
    thanks

    ReplyDelete
  16. SIR,
    it is our humble request if you could kindly discuss about a new stock idea once a month for the benefit of innumerable small investors without giving any specific buy /sell recommendation.your detailed analysis on result updates are praiseworthy. thanking you in advance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, as I said in the past, all the stocks that I follow are listed in result updates. If you look at my posts from last 1 year, there have been plenty of additions in that list. You can assume those as the new stocks that I am tracking.
      Posting any other details apart from quarterly result updates is something I might not do going ahead, understanding the spirit of guidelines given by SEBI. I fully agree with that.

      Having said that, I have always welcomed all the questions related to any of the stocks that I am tracking. I will definitely try to answer those. Please feel free to put your queries.

      Regards!!

      Delete
  17. your view about vikas eco tech

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello Kunal,

    What books do you recommend, to be read, to enhance knowledge on equity investment?

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Renju,

      Some of the better books written on investment approach, for every new investors are listed here:
      http://www.investopedia.com/articles/younginvestors/09/5-books-for-investors.asp

      However, these books will give you idea about basics and some success and failure stories to help you understand the scenario, which is only one half of the story.
      The other one, if you take my personal opinion, is experience. It is the best teacher in stock market. You will learn things with time. Your own mistakes will give you the maximum knowledge and ideas that will help you to avoid such failures again.
      This will take some time, may be few years.
      To reach there, you have to make sure that you don't just follow anyone's idea blindly for investing. Try to figure out the rationale behind investment in any company, and use the same logic to figure out more companies in various sectors on your own.

      Hope that helps!!

      Regards.

      Delete
    2. Thanks Kunal for your response. This really does help. Can you please let me know the important lessons learned by you during your investment journey so far?

      Delete
    3. LOL!!! You seem to be in a hurry.
      The number of learning is not small, they are countless. And that too, each one being equally important.

      Also, each of your learning can be applied only in context. It is not that we have all of them which are true every time. Their implementation depends on health of the nation. Just go through Defensives vs Cyclicals in stock market terms on internet, you will get one small example of what I mean. There are many such scenario.

      This is also something which you will realize or learn with time. Have patience if you really want to learn. Even after almost 10 years of my career in investing, I am still learning new things on daily basis. And as far as I believe, almost every one with n number of experience would be doing the same. :)

      “A formal education will give you knowledge; self-education will give you wisdom.”
      ― Debasish Mridha

      Regards!

      Delete
  19. Hi Kunal,
    Hope you doing good.Do you have any other stocks added recently in your radar which you feel cheap at current level? :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Satheesh, very sorry for the delayed response. Have been travelling since past many days, and hence, not very active on stock markets.

      If you take my opinion now, I think the best sectors for next 5 years are likely to infrastructure, housing finance companies, specialty chemicals and auto & auto parts companies.

      If you see the post above, I have mentioned:
      "Some of the new names that I have come across in the sector, are Bajaj Finance and PNB Housing Finance, which obviously have run up a lot in past, but still from a business perspective, they seem to have very bright future. Currently, I am not holding either of them, on account of lack of cash in hand."

      So, in a few days after the above post, I invested in both of them. Also, have been tracking Kolte Patil developers & NCL Ind from real estate. NOCIL, Omkar Specialty Chemicals and Shree Pushkar from specialty chemicals. Finance names mentioned as above plus GIC Housing Finance. Banco Products and Kingfa Science & Tech from Auto parts.

      Others are as usual that we keep on discussing every quarter.

      The companies mentioned above are just for reference for all the readers and I do not have any intentions of driving readers to any conclusion.
      Have listed all the names here, as I am not able to find much time off late for detailed discussion.
      Will still be available for queries.

      Regards!!

      Delete
  20. Hi Kunal,

    In the existing list, do you see anyone coming to end of runway - Pharma(Ajanta, Lincoln, Granules) facing huge headwinds, and Garware which ranup quite a lot. Also what is your view of Pricol, PFC. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ajanta can be a good compounder still i think once there is a revival in pharma sector, though not sure when that would be coming.
      Granules I still think has lots of potential, as the company is having plenty of growth drivers in next 2 years.
      Lincoln i m not strictly tracking off late, but it does look good. The earnings might seem muted, but that is because of company ending other businesses and focusing only in pharma space, which is in a way good for future.

      Garware might have run up a lot, but they are into monopoly business, which will keep them growing for years. Also the increasing focus of the government in defence is helping their growth. The value unlocking might not be left, but it could still deliver good returns in my opinion.

      Pricol is not finding it easy to recover from all the events that occurred around the company, like demonatization, promoter selling, amalgamation etc. The results are impressive and they are likely to be in next few quarters as well. The confidence of management in every press conference is good to see. Sometimes, the market finds difficulties in overcoming all the negatives around the company, but continued performance might help eventually. Just my thoughts.
      Not tracking PFC.

      Regards.

      Delete
  21. Hi Kunal,

    Its been sometime since your last update, hope all is well at your end. Your views on GST and the impact on the stocks you are monitoring ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sure.. will update soon..
      Professional commitments are not giving me enough time to think and write it up.. :)

      Delete
  22. Hi Kunal,
    Can you please share if you will be able to share update s basis this quarter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sure.. tomorrow..
      sorry, have been busy.. wasnt able to do it for last qtr..

      Delete
  23. Dear Kunal, Do study Lactose India ltd another wealth creating idea like most of your picks, another Granules in making Lactose India ltd.Regards

    ReplyDelete