Saturday, March 14, 2015

Gujarat Foils - Will Patience Pay Someday?



Gujarat Foils Ltd. is a part of the $7 Billion company, Topworth Group, and is the third largest manufacturer of aluminium foils and sheets in India. The company covers the entire range of products from thin gauge sheets and coils for closure stock used in the Brewery and Pharmaceutical Sectors to bare foils like Fin stock for heat exchanger fins, tagger and lidding foil for the Food & Beverage Sector, as well as consumer house foil.
From an installed capacity of 3400 TPA for sheet/coil in 1992, the company has reached a capacity of 12600 TPA today.

The company's manufacturing plant is located at GIDC, Chhatral, Kalol, Gandhinagar, Gujarat and manufactures aluminium rolled products (Sheet & Foil). The total plot area of this plant is 20,000 sq. mtrs. that includes a 9,000 sq. mtrs. built-up area within for sheds, office buildings, canteens and quarters.
The company also has 20,000 sq. mtrs. of land in Kutch area for a wind mill, and 100,000 sq. mtrs. of land near Dist. Viramgam reserved for future expansions.

As per the annual report, Consumer Products Business division has shown very good growth. Nutriwrap as a brand has strengthened itself among the top brands with national footprint. The division has maximised growth vide improvements in distribution penetration across town classes. Product portfolio has been enhanced. The base building work done provides a good platform for performance in the immediate future.
Aluminium is going through a difficult phase, globally. But, the aluminium market in India is still growing at a rate of 9 to 10% over the last five years and it is going to remain so in the near future.

The biggest positive is that  the Indian pharma companies, with the faster commercialization of product filings due to Generic Drug User Fee Act implementation, will be able to launch their products quickly as a result of shorter approval time. With this, Indian pharma companies will be pushing their products aggressively in regulated markets. With this aggressive approach, pharma industry is expected to do much better than anticipated resulting in further improvement in prospects of pharma packaging industry.

Here is the list of Company's Pharma Cleints:
1. Lupin
2. Sun Pharma
3. Macleods
4. Aurobindo
5. Cadila Pharma
6. Inventia/ Pharose Remedies
7. Impactlabs
8. Anglo French
9. Hetero Drugs
10. Zydus Cadila
11. Ipcalabs
12. Torrent Pharma
13. Ajanta Pharma
14. Granules India
15. Fourts India
16. Caplin Point
17. Alkem Laboratories


Major Risks:
1) Company is currently having very high debt, due to nature of business. The Debt:Equity is more than 2. However, the good thing is that, the debt has not increased for past 3 years. Also, the credit rating agency CARE has been continuously revising its bank facilities as the company's performance has kept on improving.
Here is the latest revision on Mar 11:
http://www.indian-commodity.com/corporate/care-revises-ratings-of-gujarat-foils-bank-facilities.aspx

2) With the Foil Industry showing signs of growth, number of new entrants are already there and more will be further coming in this sector. Cheap import from China after withdrawal of anti dumping duty resulting in cost competition in the Indian Market.

3) Due to the nature of business, and high capital requirement, the company is not paying any dividend in spite of making decent profits.

Talking about numbers, for the nine months ended Dec'14, the company has shown growth of 24% in sales and 33% growth in net profit, The company is likely to end the year with annual EPS of around 14, which means the stock is currently trading at a P/E ratio of less than 5. However, the above mentioned risk factors has been somewhere responsible for such valuations.
CAGR for last 5 years in sales has been 42% and about 101% in net profit which is an incredible achievement in such industry. It is also very tough to maintain good operating cash flow in such businesses. However, if one checks the data for past 2 years, it has been excellent.

Overall, the only questions remains, is that whether the strong numbers will overcome the risk factors in long term? If yes, then we could see a very strong re-rating in the counter, as the market cap of the company is still  a meager 50 Cr, for a company which is likely to post close to 500 Cr sales this year.
Keeping a belief in fundamentals along with good management, I am positive on company's future.
However, it is advisable that readers goes through all the details and take his/her own decision based on his/her risk profile, or if required, also after consulting finance expert.

56 comments:

  1. Sir is Kilitch Drug a classic case of undervaluation as performancewise its profits and turnover has already doubled compared to LY within 9 months of CY, it has cash bal of Rs30/-share and reserves of more than 100cr. company did well between 2008 to 2011 and then sold its few plants to multinational and paid 300% spl div to shareholders in 2012 now since last few quarters growth is also good also no debt, no pledge, promoter stake 65% with good management credentials so then why stock should be at 35 when markets in bull run? It also owns land and assets worth hundreds of crores, have i missed some aspect pls guide Sir.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Was tracking it till 2011, then left after its poor show for many quarters..
      It might have some good signs off late, but still, no comparison to what it was doing around 2010-11..
      Still a long way to go for them..

      Also, with stock markets currently trading way above its fundamentals, it is better that we enter a fundamentally strong company, rather then taking a risk, with some doubtful turnaround stories..
      This is my view and I may be wrong... :)

      Delete
  2. Hi Kunal,

    Would like to make some observations on Gujarat Foils (1) Promoters have issued 2.50 crores 10% Preference Shares (Important : Non-convertible) amounting to Rs.25 crores. Nothing unusual but they have made this at a 100% share premium. In my whole life I have never come across a single Case of a Listed entity issuing Non-Convertible Preference shares being issued at a premium and that too @ 100% premium. There used to be few cases where Redemption was proposed at a small premium of 5% to 10% but issuance of non-convertible preference shares at premium NEVER NEVER. If I take it the sincerity of promoters it is highly positive in a way they have gifted Rs.25 crores without any direct benefit.

    Now Second observation : Looking at the Shareholding pattern as on 31st March 204 and 31st December 2014. As on 31st March there were just 759 public shareholders holding 41.05% equity. Further analysis, out of this just 25 + 17 (corporate entities and large shareholders) 42 shareholders holding 36.85% shares out of 41.05% shares.
    And as on 31st December 2014, I find there are 2469 public shareholders and holding pattern is 2269 retail shareholders are holding 16.19% shares whereas Corporate entities and large shareholders numbering 98 + 27 holding just 23.85% shares as against 36.85% - A clear sale of 13% equity to retail shareholders in just nine months. It's a clear-cut case of distribution among pure retail shareholders.

    I would advise to check up the status of IPO as to when it came whether it was devolved/undersubscribed, etc.etc.

    Last and not that important - Company is not on the dividend list and probably this is the only listed entity of Topworth Group.

    Would await further comments from you and other readers.

    totalview

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What you mentioned is absolutely correct and are some of the reasons why I wasn't posting about this stock since long time.. I am tracking the stock since last 6 months...
      Suddenly I realized that now, at least for me, it is getting difficult to find a stock where I am 100% convinced about the company and its future prospects. I have to compromise somewhere or the other..
      Finally, after a long wait, I felt, this is the best possible company that I have on my radar currently. The others are not as strong as this company, in terms of data.. :)

      As you might be aware, I have always gone with the financials above other data, and somewhere there is always a possibility that I might go wrong with that..
      However, I will try to look into it in more details and keep posted..

      Delete
  3. Copper prices have tumbled the most in almost six years.The lower copper prices will benefit the OEM maker lloyd electric , which uses copper as main raw material.

    Copper prices are at the lowest point since 2009. this will lead to lower expenses and higher net profit. A save of 10 to 15% saving on raw material price will benefit to the air conditioner manufacturer. if this trend continues for year or two. the air conditioning manufacturing companies like lloyd electric and sharp inida (since i think these are are the tow companies trading at lower valuations compared to others in the industry and i feel they are decent buy at these levels)

    Would like to know your view in general on the air conitioner industry?

    Do u still see lthese companies moving to higher leves as a consumer product manufacturer and this industry will grow at a higher CAGR.

    kindly provide your comment

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not deeply into the sector..
      Will surely take a look and let you know...

      Delete
  4. Hi Kunal,

    Please if you could help me understand :" On what basis the stock price of Orient Bell is trading higher than Asian Granito's price? I understand the demand and supply theory of the market but this valuation gap has been continuing since very long time and we know markets discover the fair price in long term. But the long term has already passed and Asian Granito is a much better stock than Orient Bell in all parameters including future growth. I believe that the differential is almost 100% if you compare the statistics. Please help the investors understand the value in Asian Granito.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First thing, I also judge the company by its market cap rather than just taking P/E ratio into account. If I go by that way, Asian Granito is trading at a market cap of 267 Cr and Orient Bell at 189 Cr...

      Secondly, when you talk about valuations, like comparing P/E ratios and all, then let me tell you that it depends on lots of factors..
      If I take a look as a visitor, as I am not tracking both the stocks deeply, I would say that please check the operating cash flow for both the companies, which I feel is much more important than net profit..
      Orient Bell is having much better operating cash than Asian Granito, which may be one of the factor leading to difference in P/E ratio for both the company...

      These are strictly my views and it may be wrong, as I am not deeply into both the stocks.. :)

      Delete
    2. I am new to share market. Just wondering how to judge a share by its market cap? I did not understand how market cap affects the valuations of Orient bell and Asian granito.

      Secondly where can I see the operating cash flow of a stock?

      Delete
    3. To answer your first query, it is not easy to describe in short here...
      Probably, i will take this up in separate post..
      But you can refer to few links:
      http://stocks.about.com/od/evaluatingstocks/a/stocksmarketcap.htm
      http://www.bayt.com/en/specialties/q/129430/what-is-market-cap-and-why-is-it-more-important-than-per-share-price/
      http://fc.standardandpoors.com/sites/client/generic/axa/axa4/Article.vm?topic=5991&siteContent=8086

      Secondly, you can view a complete details about all the details of the company in one page on screener,in...

      Delete
    4. Thank you very much for the quick reply :)

      Delete
  5. Sir Would Like to have your views on Nava Bharat Ventures (NBVentures).
    The Promoter ( Nav Developers ) Have been constantly buying from The open market From last 3 quaters if v have a look at the shareholding pattern. I am Invested in the stock from Long Term Perspective. Recently i am constantly looking at the delivery volumes on NSE from past 2 weeks. Delivery Vol hav been 95-99%. From Past 1 week Disclosure has been coming and the promoter has been constantly buyin 50000 shares daily. Can u have a look at the company and let me know as to can i be holding on to it for Long term. Technically Stock has an Excellent Support @ 175.
    Thanks
    Regards,
    Vivek

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The business profile of this company is out of my coverage area, so difficult to say comment on it without proper knowledge..

      Delete
  6. Suven Life Sciences secures 2 (two) Product Patents for their NCE’s through New mechanism of action – H3 Inverse Agonist in USA & New Zealand
    Link: http://www.bseindia.com/xml-data/corpfiling/AttachLive/Suven_Life_Sciences_Ltd_160315.pdf

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. how much more can we expect from suven life sciences?
      pls comment.

      Delete
    2. Difficult to comments on price movements. As I said, it depends on lots of factors and some good news surrounding the company..
      For eg, the news above might have led to such rally yesterday...
      If it works in our favour, then thats good..

      I mostly track the quarterly results and based on it, give my views..
      For Suven, I already commented post its last Dec quarters numbers..
      Will review it again in next quarter...

      Delete
  7. Dear Sir,
    Please share your views about below stocks from their business and management point of view....
    1) Wanbury- Micro cap Pharma stock
    2) Godavari Drugs- Micro cap Pharma stock
    3) Cybertech Softwares and Systems- Micro cap IT stock
    4) Mindteck India- Micro Cap IT stock

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mindteck India is a decent company...
      Not too much positive about Wanbury..

      Not tracking other 2..

      Delete
  8. Aimco Vs Excel Industries . Which one will you prefer for a long term holding ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Difficult to comment on stocks you are not tracking deeply..
      But just based on numbers, I would go with Excel Industries above Aimco..

      Better you take decision after asking an expert deeply into the stock..

      Delete
  9. Kunal let me share with you the promoters of Gujarat foil is not investor friendly any profit further they will issue higher dividend on the preference shares and strip the profit from coming to retail investors secondly the debt repayment looks still little bleak it is only my observation pl correct me if iam wrong thank u

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The topic related to promoters and share holding pattern is already discussed above..
      I might have neglected the seriousness of such observations, by getting attracted to the other aspects like business prospectus and the numbers posted by the company so far..

      I am currently looking into those details, and will post details about it when I have something conclusive...

      Delete
    2. Hi Kunal,

      I have done further analysis of shareholding pattern, sale, etc. Please go to the shareholding pattern in back-years and how the company was acquired from erstwhile promoters, it's acquisition price, etc. It will be quite helpful to you in understanding the underlyings behind it and why those who were categorised promoters alongwith "Lodha's" are selling the stock lock stock and barrels. And I count on your understanding :-D !!!

      totalview

      Delete
    3. http://mmb.moneycontrol.com/stock-message-forum/gujaratfoils/comments/243189

      totalview

      Delete
  10. Sir ur thoughts on kopran. Godavari drugs. Orchid chemicals. All turnaround stories

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not strictly tracking these stocks, but if you have patience, Godavari Drugs and Orchid Chemicals are not bad options... But yes, there is a risk involved..
      Not much idea about Kopran...

      Delete
  11. Ricoh India made a new life-time high of Rs.626.70 and finally settled at 576.10 in a volatile market which closed weak at the end of the day. At this stage let me add that shares have been deep-pocketed by marquee HNI investors and they see much much higher price in the years to come. Just to give an indication, out of 90 lac demat shares more than 70 lac shares are now with just 200 shareholders which include HNIs/MFs/FIIs/celebrity investors. If you have bought right just sit tight and don't resort to any kind of trading. Any meaningful dip is a buy.

    totalview

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @totalview - so do u think its not bad idea to go for fresh buy even at these levels? Or can I enter into Gulshan Polyols around 260? which one u see more rewarding considering current valuations??

      Delete
    2. One is Desi growth story and the other is MNC growth story !!! Difficult to choose !!! After a gap of 12-18 months these prices will become history !!!! Both have clear visibility of growth. May be risk apportionment between the two may be an option. But put your bets where you are comfortable.

      totalview

      Delete
  12. Hi Kunal,

    Photoquip India has proposed a BoD Meeting tomorrow the 20th March 2015 to discuss the disposal of General Lighting Division(Corvi). Any idea what could be the outcome /consideration, etc.

    http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/announcements/photoquip-indias-board-meetingmarch-20-2015_1331457.html

    totalview

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Frankly speaking, I have stopped looking at Photoquip nowadays, as I see no seriousness in management about their shareholders...
      Even the results are not getting updated on time...
      Their new venture, which re-ignited our hopes, is almost ready to be sold off...
      Don't think there is much left in the company...
      Thats strictly my opinion.... :)
      Price might appreciate in anticipation of cash coming into the company on account of disposal, but that doesn't excite me to be a shareholder in the company...

      I think the negatives you mentioned in Gujarat Foils remains similar to the one in Photoquip also, as far as management is concerned. Dont you think so? :)

      Delete
    2. So finally they have stopped production of CORVI LED lights with immediate effect except for pending orders. And they will look for prospective buyers to dispose of the Lighting Division.

      Let us hope that it will be good for the Company and Photoquip will return back to profitability and now they will start rewarding shareholders by paying dividend.

      totalview

      Delete
  13. Hi, ur view on Waterbase and Dynamic industries?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Waterbase is a decent company in terms of performance in past..
      Not much idea about Dynamic Ind..

      Delete
  14. Hi. a quick view of last AR shows the unsecured loans extended to the seeming family members:

    Mona lodha: 35.22 Cr
    Sheela Lodha: 12.65 Cr.

    these are names common in other realty companies like "akshata Reality P Ltd/" and "Phoenix Realit Pvt, Ltd."

    seemingly the promoters ans associates are fueling pvt plans, at cost of GF's shareholders on a/c of high debt, high finance cost for same and no dividend

    your thoughts?



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Already looking into that matter.... Have received lots of negatives for the management already.. will put an update post on this...

      Delete
    2. Hi Kunal,

      Also check up that there is very high delivery-based volume with continuously falling prices from 95 to 56 !!! It's scary !!! I have seen some such scrips e.g.Shree Ganesh Jewellery, VIKAS WSP, Zylog Systems, Marg !!!! Crony promoters are capable of doing everything. I only wish that Gujarat Foils' promoters are an exception.

      totalview

      Delete
    3. Hi. The unsecured loans seem to be from the promoters to the company and not the other way round.

      Delete
  15. Dear Sir.. could u please express ur views on sahyadri, cybertech, tirupati sarjan and v2 retail at current price levels?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. V2 retail is a good turnaround case..
      Sahyadri is worth taking a risk, if you believe turnaround is happening in construction sector..
      Not much idea about other 2..

      Delete
    2. Thank u sir.. Can i make a fresh entry at v2retail and sahyadri at current prices.. Also, itc has hit a 52 week low.. does it make it attractive at current market price?

      Delete
    3. As I am not deeply into the stocks, it is better you consult someone who is closely tracking both the companies before taking any decision...
      I can only present my views based on overall scenario, which I did, but decision should be yours based on your risk profile..

      Delete
  16. Sure sir.. But I'm sure u must b tracking Ashiana housing n Poddar developers.. How would u rate them at current prices..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry but I am not much into Infra and Realty stocks..

      Delete
  17. Hi, your view on GEOMETRIC, KTIL and TV TODAY

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. KTIL and TV Today are decent companies..
      Not much idea about Geometric.

      Delete
  18. Gulshan Polyols has corrected from recent high of 320+ to around 260 levels !!! A correction of around 20% from the peak levels !!! It offers good opportunity to new entrants in a staggered manner with atleast 24 months' perspective.

    totalview

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Block deal took place today of around 6 Lac shares...

      Delete
    2. Now 16.30% of the expanded equity is held by Antara (Foreign Portfolio Investor) and Reliance Mutual Fund (Small and Mid-Cap Fund).

      Antara has subscribed 9.35 lac shares@ Rs.175 through issue of equity and convertible warrants whereas Reliance Mutual Fund has purchased 5.95 lac shares through a Block deal from the promoters @ Rs.250 !!!!

      It means two Institutional investors have vetted and done due diligence on Gulshan Polyols.

      Expect much higher levels during CY2015 !!!

      totalview

      Delete
  19. Hi Kunal. also like to find value picks like u just did. I find Gujarat Foils interesting and first thing, I am going to do Monday is buy some. Also, I would like to know your view on
    1. Neo Corp,

    2. Sudar Industries (Too much risk, I know but I am willing to take even if 10% possibilities are there).

    3. Asian Granito: As you said, you are not tracking Asian Granito, but if you get time, please study it. Looks a rel gem.

    4. Pricol (Suffering due to Aggressive management, but results will definitely improve)

    5. Kwality (Too much indervalued)

    6. ArchidPly (Nice Plywood company with strong business model)

    7. Ganesh Housing (Big Real Estate player in Ahemadabad, one of the most focused city of the govt).

    I still have a much bigger list.!!! Would appreciate if we could have a more interactive sessions. Thanks :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Apart from negatives mentioned in the original post, there are many other big negatives about the shareholding pattern also, which are discussed in the comment section..
      Pls refer to those as well before concluding...

      Regarding the names mentioned above, I was tracking Neo Corp, Archidply, and was positive on those 2 names..
      Didn't like Sudar, Kwality much because of their history..
      Not tracking others...

      Delete
  20. Sir,

    whats your view on Amtek India, Polyplex corporation, MIC electronics?

    Your advice will be really helpful..

    Regards,
    Arjeet

    ReplyDelete